Comprehensive side-by-side comparative table of 4 Madhabs

7:04 PM | BY ZeroDivide EDIT

Comparative Table of Sunni Madhabs

AspectHANAFIMALIKISHAFI'IHANBALI
Founder

Abu Hanifa (699-767 CE)

Malik ibn Anas (711-795 CE)

Al-Shafi'i (767-820 CE)

Ahmad ibn Hanbal (780-855 CE)

Followers

~45% of Sunnis

~25% of Sunnis

~25% of Sunnis

~5% of Sunnis

Main Regions

Turkey, Central Asia, Indian subcontinent, Balkans

North/West Africa, Upper Egypt, Sudan

East Africa, Southeast Asia, Yemen

Saudi Arabia, Qatar, UAE

Methodology

AspectHANAFIMALIKISHAFI'IHANBALI
Primary Approach

Maximum reasoning (ra'y)

Medinan practice (amal)

Systematic hadith authentication

Textualist ; relies on a vast corpus of over 30,000 hadith

Qiyas (Analogy)

Extensive use

Limited use; rejects excess qiyas

Restricted use

Minimal use, only in cases of necessity

Istihsan (Juristic Preference)

Yes

No

No

No

Custom ('urf)

Most accepting

Moderate acceptance

Minimal acceptance

Rejected

Hadith Approach

Fewer hadith accepted due to strict conditions; weak hadith preferred over qiyas

The practice of Medina is prioritized over isolated hadith reports

Systematic authentication

Maximum corpus (30,000+)

Public Interest

Limited use

Yes (masalih mursalah)

No

No (rejects istislah)

Prayer (Salah)

AspectHANAFIMALIKISHAFI'IHANBALI
Qunut Supplication

In Witr prayer only

In Fajr prayer only

Daily in Fajr prayer

In Witr, during the last half of Ramadan

Raising Hands

Only for the opening takbir

Only for the opening takbir

Multiple times, including at ruku' and rising

Multiple times

"Ameen"

Silent

Silent

Loud in congregation

Silent

Arm Position

Folded on chest

At the sides (sadl)

Folded

Folded

Feet Position

Shoulder-width apart

Together

Close together

Slightly apart

Ablution (Wudu)

AspectHANAFIMALIKISHAFI'IHANBALI
Touching a Woman

Breaks wudu

Does not break wudu, unless there is desire

Always breaks wudu (any skin contact)

Breaks wudu if there is desire

Bleeding

Breaks wudu

No effect

No effect

No effect

Vomiting

A mouthful breaks wudu

No effect

No effect

No effect

Laughter in Prayer

Breaks wudu

No effect

No effect

No effect

Dog Saliva

Wash once

Wash once

Wash 7 times, with one wash being with soil

Wash 7 times

Eating Camel Meat

No effect

No effect

No effect

Breaks wudu

Fasting (Sawm)

AspectHANAFIMALIKISHAFI'IHANBALI
Eating Forgetfully

Does not break the fast

Does not break the fast

Does not break the fast

Does not break the fast

Intentional Vomiting

Breaks the fast

Breaks the fast

Breaks the fast

Breaks the fast

Hijama (Cupping)

No effect

No effect

Breaks the fast

Breaks the fast

Continuous Fasting

Allowed

Prohibited

Allowed

Allowed

Zakat

AspectHANAFIMALIKISHAFI'IHANBALI
Vegetables/Fruits

No zakat required

Zakat required on all produce

Zakat required on specific items

Zakat required on specific items

Honey

Zakat required

No zakat required

No zakat required

No zakat required

Trade Goods

Required

Required

Mandatory, with strict calculations

Required

Marriage & Divorce

AspectHANAFIMALIKISHAFI'IHANBALI
Wali (Guardian) Requirement

Not required for an adult woman

Mandatory for all women

Required for a virgin, but not for a previously married woman

Mandatory for all women

Witnesses for Marriage

Not required for the validity of the contract

2 required

2 are mandatory

Recommended

Woman's Consent

An adult woman can contract her own marriage

Consent is given through the wali

Consent is given through the wali

Consent is given through the wali

Triple Divorce in One Sitting

Counts as 3 divorces

Counts as 1 revocable divorce

Counts as 3 if intended as such

The effect depends on the man's intention

Legal Philosophy & Modern Application

AspectHANAFIMALIKISHAFI'IHANBALI
Rationalism Level

Highest

Moderate-High, practice-based

Moderate-Low, systematic

Lowest, most textual

Flexibility

Most flexible

Pragmatic

Systematic

Most rigid

Modern Application

Influenced Ottoman codes and modern reforms

Used in minority fiqh and migration contexts

Influential in commercial and banking law

Forms the basis of the Saudi legal system; influential on Salafi thought