It was interesting talking about sexuality and myth, and we tried to introduce the concept of sex and its importance even in spiritual practice. But let's discuss what it all means in my personal life. Let's forget about culture, spirituality, and religion. What role does sex play in my life and my spiritual practice? Let's focus on that.
Before I ask for your opinion, let me share my thoughts on this topic because I have a personal motivation that I didn't mention in our previous discussion. As a Muslim, and according to the law, circumcision is practiced among Jewish people, and every male person is required to undergo it. Circumcision is, by medical terminology, a form of genital mutilation. If you think about it that way, it’s a serious and irreversible procedure for your entire life. Millions of people across cultures undergo it without questioning why they have to do it. Is it just a blind symbol, or does it have real significance? That was my main motivation. Over the last 10 to 15 years, I have always wondered about the meaning of circumcision.
If you ask religious leaders, like those in Islam, they may say, "It's a divine commandment; you have to do it." Others who are spiritually inclined but not particularly scientifically minded might say, "It’s for cleanliness." Some argue that circumcision is beneficial for health and prevents certain cancers. In my personal opinion, I believe this is all misguided. Historically, during the time of the Egyptian pharaohs, they weren’t aware of these health benefits; they didn’t know about various viruses or many types of cancer. Similarly, people were practicing circumcision even before the time of Abraham; it didn’t start with him.
The reasons I mentioned do not align with personal belief, and if you dig deeper, nothing stands firm. So I looked into who practiced circumcision or castration before this religious connotation. It must have originated from myth. The first person who was castrated was Osiris. If we study Osiris alongside Kronos, we can see that the phallus symbolizes creativity and progeny—an endless cycle of generation. The phallic symbol represents procreation and regeneration; it embodies continuous creativity, like the creative force of God.
Now, why would this creativity need to be cut down? That’s the mystery. If God symbolizes creativity and we use the phallus as a representation of that creativity, then why would there be a need for castration? It doesn’t make sense.
Historically, as Plato noted, all these Greek myths, like those involving Zeus and Kronos, depict glorified humans. Plato believed that these figures serve as allegories to convey deeper stories. He had two schools of thought: the exoteric and the esoteric. Neo-Platonism emerged from the esoteric aspect, while the exoteric is more widely understood. Plato personally believed these figures were not gods in the traditional sense but rather representations of ancient humans.
If I can connect these human figures to the divine, then as a spiritual seeker, hypothetically, if I want to justify this whole scenario, it suggests this: God is continuously creating, like vegetation that grows and dies, new generations arise, and diverse species emerge. This cycle never stops. What, then, is the end goal of all this creativity? Traditional religious people across various traditions indicate that humanity is the culmination of all creation. In every monotheistic culture, humans are considered the pinnacle of creation.
If you believe that humanity represents the final destination of creativity, then this suggests a sort of ending. In my view, the emergence of human beings signifies that creativity itself has come to a pause. This aligns with the idea of castration: symbolically, humanity limits the creative force of God, Ouranos, meaning He can no longer create new species.
Even if I travel to Alpha Centauri and find a sentient being, they must understand duality, such as good and bad. They must grasp self versus non-self. As humans, we can comprehend these concepts. So, I stand as a representative of humanity—the culmination of creation. Even if other beings do not resemble me, I share a profound connection with them, embodying the terminal point of all existence.
Now, if one considers themselves as the ultimate conclusion of creation, then circumcision symbolizes sealing this fate—as in the English phrase, "to seal a deal." Circumcision represents that creativity stops with humanity. Humans, in this sense, become the final vessel or host for the divine orchestration, which, in tradition, indicates that creation and creativity ceased with humanity. However, if I personally choose to undergo circumcision, I may no longer create. Biologically, I still have responsibilities. How can I fulfill these? By symbolically carrying out circumcision as part of a ritual.
This ancient practice of circumcision, potentially prehistorical and predating even Osiris, suggests that humanity is indeed the crown jewel of creation—a symbol of purpose and culmination.
Now, what is the relationship between sex and the divine? This is another intriguing concept that I believe you can elucidate further. For example, in your view, how does sex relate to samadhi? You mentioned samadhi is akin to Nirvana; it represents liberation—the ultimate human experience. Describe how one might achieve samadhi or Nirvana through sex symbolically.
I think it’s possible to reach that state through various means. I know you mentioned you have a medical background. In a materialistic model, while there are finite pathways to these experiences, many different methods can lead there—sex can induce such states, as can psychedelics, meditation, and other activities.
Sexual experiences may be fleeting and not enduring, similar to early stages of meditation, where you might only catch a glimpse of that state. It requires much practice to stabilize yourself within it. In that state, there is no separation—self and other become one. As you pointed out earlier, in sex—even at the level of orgasm, with that peak of pleasure—the union and desire to completely connect with another person allow for a transcending of one's limitations, even if only for a brief moment of pure connection.
Exactly. In mythological terms, if I translate what you just shared into the Osiris and Kronos narratives, there’s a consistent theme regarding the problem of death. Osiris represents the necessity of dying, as does Jesus, who was told he must die. Paul expressed that if he doesn’t die, how can humanity achieve liberation? Even in the Old Testament, when God rested on the seventh day, this too signifies a kind of death or retirement. The concept of God's death is pervasive across traditions.
Why must God die? It relates to materiality. The instant you introduce matter, decay becomes inevitable. Yet, God is also eternal. To truly know oneself, God had to create material existence, but in doing so, the nature of temporality was introduced—wherein time becomes a measure of objects and experiences.
Kronos, representing time, serves as the ruler among gods—even Saturn represents time in astrology. He was revered as the highest deity, as he remains most steady—moving only once every 33 years. Thus, he governs time due to his steadiness.
However, with the introduction of time, death becomes a necessity. This is why death intertwines with the divine narrative. Actualizing the mystery of death and resurrection is the core of various spiritual traditions.
Sex, then, symbolizes a secret means of overcoming death. As God, desiring to manifest oneself to both self and others, the creation of matter introduces death—creating materiality also brings the specter of mortality. The goal of seeking awareness is thwarted by this inherent barrier. However, within the material realm, if matter combines and overcomes death, then it transcends the ultimate boundary.
Thus, sex becomes a profound mechanism for transcending mortality. People instinctively seek immortality, since we, as reflections of God, harbor that inherent drive. As Freudian psychology suggests, both sex and death are interconnected themes. The drive for immortality, deeply rooted within us, signifies that the physical expression of sex connects humanity to the divine—our progeny becomes a form of immortality.
So, this means that sex represents not only pleasure to us but embodies our connection to the divine essence. While we may refer to it as orgasm, at its core, it is the divine's experience. Hence, achieving God through sex can spark incredible experiences like samadhi or a reunion with the divine.
Thank you for taking the time to discuss this depth; I think not many people consider sex as a symbol of liberation. I'll probably refine my thoughts into a clearer form, as most will not understand or will misinterpret them. Nevertheless, I hope to share these ideas, as they are significant.
I believe you should present these ideas, as they deserve to be expressed. It’s clear that my earlier readings of Freudian psychology led me to believe you were relaying this very narrative. While many may not make that association, I felt a deep resonance with your thoughts and wanted to share that connection.
Thank you for the conversation; I hope we can continue our discussion in the future.
///
Sure! Here's a rephrased version of the text:
It was fascinating to discuss sexuality and myth, especially as we explored the idea of integrating sex into spiritual practices. However, let’s shift gears and examine what this means in my personal life. Let’s put aside culture, spirituality, and religion for a moment, and focus on how sex influences my spiritual journey. Before I ask for your thoughts, I’d like to share my perspective on this topic.
My interest in this area stems from my personal experience as a Muslim, where circumcision is a requirement; similar practices exist in Judaism as well. This procedure, viewed through a medical lens, can be classified as genital mutilation because it is an irreversible surgical action affecting individuals for life. Despite this, millions of people undergo it without questioning its significance or understanding whether it's merely a blind tradition or holds deeper meaning. I have wrestled with this question for years: What is the real purpose of circumcision? When I ask religious leaders, they often cite divine commandments, while others might claim it’s for cleanliness or health benefits. In my view, these justifications lack validity.
Historically, even in ancient Egypt, health benefits were not a recognized concept, and circumcision predates the biblical Abraham. Thus, the reasoning surrounding circumcision—divine command, cleanliness, or health—is not compelling upon deeper investigation. This led me to explore who practiced circumcision or similar rituals prior to these religious contexts, prompting me to consider the mythological aspects.
For instance, Osiris is often associated with castration. Studying the symbolism of figures like Osiris and Kronos reveals that the phallus embodies creativity and regeneration—essentially endless creativity. Given that God is the ultimate creator, why would there be any rationale for castration? The apparent contradiction piqued my interest.
Plato suggested that mythological figures like Zeus and Kronos represent glorified versions of ancient humans, serving to convey deeper truths. If we connect the divine with humanity, a spiritual believer might see that God’s endless creativity somehow culminates in humans, suggesting we are the final expression of this creative force.
So, if humans are the endpoint of creation, does that metaphorically signify a cessation of creativity? In this perspective, castration could symbolize this termination of divine creativity—whereupon human existence becomes a ‘host’ for the divine. In the mythological narrative, Kronos’ act of cutting off creation parallels the idea of finality.
Exploring this further, we can see that the cyclical nature of generations means that creativity inherently leads to death. My belief is that this connection between sex and the divine is vital. Ultimately, achieving a state akin to samadhi—or nirvana—can emerge through sexuality, as both are forms of transcending individual boundaries for a moment of pure unity.
Sexual experiences often produce temporary states akin to spiritual union, much like meditation or psychedelics. While these moments may not last long, they offer profound insights into the interconnectedness of all things. In both sexual experiences and spiritual practices, the dissolution of self-boundaries can lead to a sense of oneness.
If we reinterpret these ideas within mythological frameworks, we see that death remains a recurring theme. Osiris and other mythological figures experienced death as part of their narratives—often as a precursor to rebirth or liberation. This speaks to the deeper mystery of death and the significance of sexuality as a means of transcending mortality.
Understanding the relationship between sex and the divine highlights sex as a crucial tool for transcending death and fostering continuity. In this light, pleasure might be seen as a divine imperative—an integral part of material existence that allows one to experience life, death, and rebirth. Human beings, in facing mortality, find meaning through procreation and generational continuity.
My motivation for discussing these themes stems from an interest in understanding the interconnectedness of sex, spirituality, and the quest for liberation—a perspective not commonly addressed. I acknowledge that many might dismiss these ideas as irrelevant, but I believe it’s crucial to engage with these deeper connections. Your insights into these concepts resonate with me, underscoring the parallels in our thinking.
I appreciate your willingness to explore this topic with me, and I look forward to future discussions. Thank you for your time and insights tonight.